The short answer
On a $350,000 property renting for $2,500/month with $800/month in expenses, cap rate is 5.4% and gross yield is 8.57% — two different numbers because gross yield ignores expenses entirely. With no mortgage entered, monthly cash flow is a healthy $1,575. Add a $2,000/month mortgage payment and cash flow flips to -$425 — the same property, profitable unlevered but underwater once financed.
Key takeaways
- This calculator takes your monthly mortgage payment as a direct input — enter $0 to see an unlevered (all-cash) return, or your actual payment to see the levered picture.
- Gross yield (8.57% here) only divides rent by price. Cap rate (5.4%) nets out operating expenses first — always check both, since gross yield alone overstates true return.
- The same $350,000 property swings from +$1,575/month cash flow with no mortgage to -$425/month with a $2,000 mortgage payment — a reminder that financing terms can make or break a deal that looks fine on paper unlevered.
- NOI ($18,900/year in this example) is the number that feeds both cap rate and, once debt service is subtracted, cash flow — get comfortable calculating it before trusting either ratio.
Cap rate vs. gross yield
Gross yield = annual rent ÷ price = $30,000 ÷ $350,000 = 8.57%
NOI = effective income − expenses = $28,500 − $9,600 = $18,900
Cap rate = NOI ÷ price = $18,900 ÷ $350,000 = 5.4%
Gross yield is the fastest, roughest screening number — just rent divided by price — and it is easy to compute for any listing without knowing expenses. But it ignores vacancy, taxes, insurance, and maintenance entirely, so it always overstates the real return. Cap rate takes those costs into account by starting from NOI instead of gross rent, which is why it lands nearly 3.2 percentage points lower in this example (5.4% vs. 8.57%). When comparing properties, gross yield can rank two deals in the wrong order if their expense ratios differ — cap rate is the more reliable number.
How the mortgage input changes everything
Unlike calculators that build a mortgage payment from a loan amount and rate, this one asks for your monthly mortgage payment directly — which makes it easy to see exactly how financing changes an otherwise identical deal:
| Scenario | Monthly Cash Flow |
|---|---|
| All-cash (no mortgage) | $1,575.00 |
| $2,000/month mortgage | -$425.00 |
Cap rate and gross yield never change with the mortgage input — they are both calculated before debt service. Only cash flow moves. That separation is useful: it lets you evaluate whether a property is fundamentally sound (via cap rate) independent of how you plan to finance it, then layer your actual or hypothetical mortgage payment on top to see what it does to monthly cash flow.
Related calculators
- Real Estate Investment Calculator — builds the mortgage from a loan amount and rate, plus a 5-year projection.
- Mortgage Calculator — find the exact monthly payment to plug into this calculator.
- Rent vs. Buy Calculator — for evaluating a home to live in rather than rent out.